The 5 Best Pizza Shops Around Aspen

Pizza in the Roaring Fork Valley is a comfort food staple — the late-night go-to, the family dinner solution, the après-ski reward and the takeout box that somehow disappears in one sitting. The Best of Aspen, Snowmass and Basalt contest highlighted places where crust, sauce and toppings come together with personality, whether the pies lean crisp and simple or hearty and loaded. These are spots where a slice can shift the mood of the day, and sharing a pie often turns into sharing stories.

New York Pizza

New York Pizza is the definition of a dependable favorite — a place where the ovens stay hot late, the slices land fast and the vibe is as casual as it gets. The pies are straightforward in the best way: crisp crust, balanced toppings and a style that makes grabbing “just one more slice” almost inevitable. It’s the kind of pizza joint that feels like part of the community, equally suited to a quick stop or a long, laughter-filled night.

Taster’s Pizza

Taster’s Pizza in Snowmass Village leans into hearty, satisfying slices with toppings that don’t hold back. The pies are built for sharing, refueling and relaxing — especially after a day on the mountain. The atmosphere is laid-back and welcoming, the sort of place where ski gear, hoodies and big appetites fit right in. It’s comfort food that arrives without pretense, just warmth and flavor.

Timbo’s Pizza

Timbo’s Pizza in Basalt brings a local, home-style feel to its pies, focusing on familiar, satisfying flavors. The crust has just enough chew, the toppings are generous and the menu offers something for everyone — from classic combos to family-favorite specialties. It’s the kind of pizzeria that becomes a routine stop because it delivers exactly what you want: good pizza and a relaxed atmosphere.

Highlands Alehouse

Highlands Alehouse offers pizza with a lively, social setting at the base of Aspen Highlands. It’s a natural après spot — where conversations spill outside, boots stay on and pizzas land in the middle of crowded tables. The menu balances classic flavors and creative twists, making it easy to pair a slice with a cold drink and a post-slope sense of satisfaction. It’s casual, cheerful and always buzzing.

Mezzaluna Willits

Mezzaluna Willits brings an Italian-inspired approach to pizza, with blistered crusts and bright toppings that feel light and flavorful. The atmosphere is warm and friendly, making it a reliable choice for dinners that stretch a little longer. Their pizzas pair well with shared appetizers, a glass of wine and conversation that unfolds at an easy pace. It’s relaxed dining with a touch of elegance.

Thanks, ChatGPT.